Peer Reviews Peer Reviews All pages
On this page

Peer Reviews

Peer review lets the people you trust read a finished manuscript and comment on the exact passages, inside Alfred Scholar. Alfred can read it too, and check each claim against the source it cites.

How it works

  1. You mark the manuscript Final.
  2. You assign reviewers. They see that manuscript and nothing else in your workspace.
  3. Reviewers highlight passages and leave comments.
  4. You reply, revise, and resolve each comment as you deal with it.

Before you start

  • The manuscript must be Final. Turn on the Final switch at the top of the editor. See Writing Manuscripts.
  • Each reviewer must be in your workspace with the Reviewer role. Invite them from Settings, then Members. See Team Members.
  • Your plan sets how many reviewers you can have: 1 on Plus, 3 on Pro and unlimited on Lab. Basic has none.

Only the workspace owner can assign and remove reviewers.

Assign a reviewer

  1. Click Peer reviews in the sidebar and open the manuscript.
  2. Click Reviewers at the top.
  3. Click Add.
  4. Choose a name under Workspace reviewers.

The reviewer gets an email, and the manuscript appears in their Peer reviews.

A manuscript open for review with the Reviewers panel showing the Add popover and a reviewer to choose under Workspace reviewers.
Choose a reviewer from your workspace

To remove a reviewer, open the Reviewers panel and click Remove reviewer beside their name. They lose access at once. Their comments stay.

Review a manuscript (for reviewers)

  1. Click Peer reviews in the sidebar.
  2. Open the manuscript you were asked to read.
The Peer reviews page listing two manuscripts to read, each with its word count and when it was last updated.
The manuscripts you have been asked to read

The manuscript opens read-only, with the comments beside it. Reviewing works on a tablet or a computer.

Comment on a passage

  1. Select the text you want to comment on.
  2. Pick a highlight colour and click Comment in the menu above the selection.
  3. Type your comment and click Comment.

Leave a general comment

  1. Open the Comments panel.
  2. Without selecting any text, type in the comment box and click Comment.

Reply to a comment

  1. Click Reply under the comment.
  2. Type your reply and send it.
A manuscript open for review, with highlighted passages in the text and the Comments panel beside it holding a reviewer's comment and one from Alfred.
Comments sit beside the passages they quote

Read and resolve feedback (for authors)

  1. Open the manuscript from Peer reviews and click Comments at the top.
  2. Click a highlight in the text to find its comment, and reply if you need to.
  3. When you have dealt with it, click Resolve comment (the check mark).

Resolved comments fold away under a resolved count at the bottom of the panel, so you can still read them.

Ask Alfred to review it

Alfred reads the whole manuscript the way a supervisor would, section by section, then checks each claim against the source it cites. Alfred does not use a reviewer seat.

Reviews by Alfred are included on Pro (1 a month, checking up to 10 cited sources), on Lab (4 a month, checking up to 30) and in the 7-day trial. Basic and Plus do not include them.

  1. Open the Final manuscript from Peer reviews.
  2. Click Alfred at the top.
  3. Click Ask Alfred to read it.

Alfred reads the sections first, then each cited source. You can close the panel while it works. To check a revised draft, click Read it again.

What Alfred checks

  • Citations: markers that point at a source that no longer exists, one paper cited under two records, DOIs that do not resolve, and styles that drift. If your reference list was typed by hand, also entries that are never cited and markers with no entry.
  • Claims against their sources: whether the source supports the claim, the claim goes further than the source, or the source does not support it.
  • Argument and method: claims without support, conclusions the evidence does not reach, contradictions, unjustified choices, missing limitations and unstated assumptions.
  • Writing: the same things the writing check looks for.

Read the findings

Findings arrive in Alfred’s panel, grouped by topic, such as citations, claims and evidence, argument, method and writing. Each one is marked Must fix, Should fix or Consider, and names its passage.

  • Accept a finding and it becomes a comment on that passage, like any other comment.
  • Dismiss it and nothing is written.

There is no score and no verdict. Each run is a numbered round, so you can compare round 2 with round 1.

Alfred's review panel beside a manuscript, with findings grouped by topic and marked by how much they matter, each quoting its passage and offering Accept and Dismiss.
Alfred's findings, for you to accept or dismiss

What Alfred could not check

Alfred can only check a citation it can reach: a paper in your library, an open-access paper, or an abstract. What this round covered lists the sources it read and the ones it could not, whose claims were not checked. Read it before you treat a clean round as a clean manuscript.

Alfred cannot tell you whether the manuscript is good, or whether text was written by AI. It does not replace your supervisor or a journal’s reviewers. Run it before you send the draft to them, so their time goes on what only they can catch.

Export or print

  1. Click Export at the top of the review.
  2. Choose Download as PDF or Print manuscript.

Next steps